Discussion (red)

General

ID	Subject	Cat	Status	Page	Clause	Paragraph	Created	Last Comment	Proposer
1508	TR 90-2 Duplication of LDeviceOverride	Ed2	Discussion (red)	175	Annex D		02 Sep 16	20 Sep 16	T. Paukatong
1505	Requirement of Detection of duplicate GOOSE message by a subscriber IED	Ntp	Discussion (red)				04 Aug 16	02 Jan 24	C. awasthi
179	IED parameters not exposed in object models	Ed2	Discussion (red)				04 Aug 05	08 Aug 05	S. Klein
160	Pulse configuration	Ed2	Discussion (red)	RREC, PTRC, DPC			02 May 05	10 Oct 06	K. Brand

Part 3 (2003)

607	Definition	Ed2	Discussion (red)	25	5.7.4.2		19 Feb 08	22 Feb 08	R. Schimmel
602	Definition of protective functions shall operate autonomously	Ed2	Discussion (red)	15	4.2.3		19 Feb 08	22 Feb 08	R. Schimmel

Part 5 (2013-01; Edition 2)

1492	Over speed protection	Ed3	Discussion (red)	33	8.5.3		04 May 16	13 May 16	E. Gondra Churruca
1379	Consistency	Ed2	Discussion (red)		8.7.1 and 8.7.2		27 Apr 15	02 Jun 15	P. LHUILLIER

Part 10 (2012; Edition 2)

1482

Remove cAss4 as it is not abstract

Ed2

Discussion (red)

36

6.2.5.7.1

17 Mar 16

05 Apr 16

E. San Telmo

Part 9-3 (Precision Time Protocol Profile)

1636	BC forwarding of obsolete information	Ed2	Discussion (red)	11	7.6.1		02 Nov 18	12 Nov 18	H. Kirrmann
1595	Delay Measurment with clocks in different domains	Ed2	Discussion (red)	10	7.5		26 Jul 17	08 Nov 18	H. Kirrmann

Part 7-3 (2020; Edition 2.1)

1878

Use of Percentage Pct is confusing

Discussion (red)

122

8.8

2

11 Jul 23

19 Dec 25

B. Muschlitz

Part 7-4 (2020; Edition 2.1)

2028	No way to express Numerical Scaling Factor (Matching Factor) for PDIF		Discussion (red)	168	6.11.2	Table 103	04 Feb 26	04 Feb 26	R. Massink
2005	Understanding the values of 'ClockSyncLockingKind'		Discussion (red)	433	7.2.11	Table 219	17 Oct 25	07 Feb 26	M. Häcker
1999	Relationship between Annex A and substitution need clarification		Discussion (red)	454	Annex A	Table A.1	10 Sep 25	16 Sep 25	B. Day
1977	SwgTmms description confusing		Discussion (red)	263	6	6.1310	06 May 25	14 May 25	C. GHAFARI
1976	Blocking of electrical outputs without consideration of their purposes		Discussion (red)	454	Annex A	Table A.1, Table A.2	25 Apr 25	02 Jul 25	M. Häcker
1975	Modes "blocked" and "test/blocked" impact electrical outputs only, not data		Discussion (red)	454	Annex A	Table A.1, Table A.2	25 Apr 25	02 May 25	M. Häcker
1966	InRef / ExtRef Mapping at Data Attribute level		Discussion (red)	66	6.2.2.2	Table 5 – Data objects of DomainLN	25 Feb 25	23 Jun 25	D. Gopinath
1929	LCCH - ChLiv/RedChLiv		Discussion (red)	129	6.3.4	Table 46	31 May 24	26 Nov 25	T. Windler
1793	Behaviour of output contacts when LN is in blocked mode		Discussion (red)	397	Annex A	Table A.1	28 Sep 21	07 Feb 24	M. Häcker

Part 9-2 (2020; Edition 2.1)

1964

Which value to be used to mark invalid data in backwards compatibility

Discussion (red)

13

8.6

Table 21

13 Feb 25

18 Feb 25

M. Häcker

Part 8-1 (2020; Edition 2.1)

1945

Need to add a note about Ethernet Frame Size

Discussion (red)

179

C.1

3

22 Oct 24

21 Jan 25

H. Falk

Part 7-500 (2017)

1798

Incorrect signal from RBRF to RREC

Discussion (red)

71

15.6.2

Figure 40

22 Oct 21

15 Oct 22

K. Gray

Part 7-420 (2021; Edition 2, DER)

1971

EqGn in DGEN, EqSto in DSTO, and EqLod in DLOD

Discussion (red)

234, 246, and 257

A.3.1.7.3, A.3.1.8.3, and A.3.1.9.3

Table A.34, A.36, and A.38

09 Apr 25

14 Nov 25

T. Otani

Part 6 (2025; Edition 2.2)

2004	In XSD, the enumeration tPredefinedBasicTypeEnum contains basic types that are not used in part 7-2,		Discussion (red)	165	9.5.4.2	Attribute basic types	14 Oct 25	01 Dec 25	A. Dehouck
1990	Understanding in ICT an UUID in ObjectReference defined by an SCT		Discussion (red)	257	Annex G	Table G.1	05 Aug 25	10 Oct 25	C. Bloch
1988	Upgrading rules of IEDName.apRef does not consider the service capabilty of an access point		Discussion (red)	290	I.5.3.1	I.5.3.1	04 Aug 25	10 Oct 25	T. Dufaure
1987	GSEControl / SampledValueControl IEDName element may point to an LN		Discussion (red)	130	Table 28	9.3.10	04 Aug 25	01 Dec 25	T. Dufaure
1983	Configuration data-attributes(FC=CF) and there default values		Discussion (red)	167	9.5.4.4	9.5.4.4	07 Jul 25	today 08:36	M. Schicklgruber
1982	Specified values for Dbpos/Quality in SCL		Discussion (red)	160/161	9.5.4	Table 45	07 Jul 25	10 Oct 25	M. Schicklgruber
1969	Services LogSettings has no LogRef attribute		Discussion (red)	1	1	1	04 Mar 25	10 Oct 25	R. Schimmel
1965	SecurityEnable or SecurityEnabled		Discussion (red)	1	1	1	24 Feb 25	10 Oct 25	R. Schimmel
1960	management of the ConnectedAP physical information		Discussion (red)	Table 36, Table 39	Table 36, Table 39	Table 36, Table 39	10 Feb 25	10 Oct 25	T. Dufaure
1955	Relationship between GSESettings and GSE		Discussion (red)	147	9.4.4	1	24 Jan 25	10 Oct 25	C. Bloch
1954	discrepancy schema vs pdf - tHeader		Discussion (red)	53	9.1	definition of tHeader	23 Jan 25	10 Oct 25	T. Dufaure
1953	Format of Header.version, revision for system usage in MinRequestSCDFile		Discussion (red)	52	9.1	9.1	14 Jan 25	10 Oct 25	T. Dufaure
1952	ExtRef unicity rules		Discussion (red)	138	9.3.13 Binding to external signals	After table 33	10 Jan 25	10 Oct 25	C. Bloch
1951	I35 modification of data model doesn't accomodate dual role (ICT + SCT) tools		Discussion (red)	241	Annex G	Table G.1 Row I35	07 Jan 25	13 Oct 25	Z. Wormgoor