1739   Contradictory optionality of GOOSE_PDU goID

Created: 18 Nov 2020

Status: Editorial

Part: Part 8-1 (2020; Edition 2.1)

Links:

Page: 161 (consolidated)

Clause: A.1

Paragraph: IECGoosePDU

Issue

Am1 consolidated document is missing identifying goID ASN1 production as optional as it has been in all previous versions of 61850-8-1.

The Amd document does NOT specify removal of "optional" but the consolidated document now incorrectly indicates that goID is mandatory in the GOOSE PDU. This seems a simple copying error.

Proposal

Change in the consolidated document:
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING,"
to
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING OPTIONAL,"

Discussion Created Status
Approved Editorial 12 Dec 23 Editorial
No comment since december. Move to Editorial:
The consolidated version shall be changed to match the AMD document.

Change in the consolidated document:
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING,"
to
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING OPTIONAL," 		28 Feb 23 Approval (Editoral)
The consolidated should be updated to match with the AMD (e.g. OPTIONAL should be the result). 20 Dec 22 Discussion (red)
Proposed change:

The presence of the goID service parameter in a publisher conformant to the Ed2.1 shall is mandatory in the IECGoosePdu.

A Subscriber that does not receive a GoID from a publisher conformant to a previous version of the standard, shall assume that it is equal to the default GoID value defined in 18.1.1.1.1

The ASN.1 Production shall be modified to fullfil the backward compatibility of Subscribers:

Change in the consolidated document:
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING,"
to
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING OPTIONAL," 		20 Dec 22 Discussion (red)
The presence of the goID service parameter in a publisher conformant to the Ed2.1 shall is mandatory in the IECGoosePdu.

A Subscriber that does not receive a GoID from a publisher conformant to a previous version of the standard, shall assume that it is equal to the default GoID value defined in 18.1.1.1.1

The ASN.1 Production shall be modified to fullfil the backward compatibility of Subscribers:

Change in the consolidated document:
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING,"
to
"goID [3] IMPLICIT VISIBLE-STRING OPTIONAL,"
27 Nov 20 Accepted

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer

Tissue DB v. 24.4.30.1