925 Presence of i or f attribute - Problem with writing

Created
26 Sep 2012
Status
In Force (green)Closed: the solution is part of the standard. No further comments are taken. Show the workflow
Part
Part 7-3 (2010; Edition 2)
Links
None
Page
Clause
7.5.8
Paragraph
Category
Issue may impact interoperability of implementations of Edition 2

Issue

Late comment form Germany / UML Modeling team Discussion:
The service parameter for control ctlVal has the type analogueValue. It means it has f and i as possible parameter. It shoudn’t be permitted to write both at the same time.

Proposal

A new constructed attribute class "AnalogueValueCtl" shall be defined with a similar definition as AnalogValue, but the condition shall be such that either the attribute i or the attribute f shall be present.

In CDC APC, the service parameter ctlVal shall be of type AnalogueValueCtl (instead of type AnalogueValue)

DiscussionCreated
In Force (green) Editor 7-3 Meeting, 2014-01-06:
The same Problem exists as well for Analogue Settings - so this type "AnalogueValueCtl" shall as well be used for setVal in the CDC ASG
06 Jan 14
In Force (green) 05 Dec 12
Ballot Period 26 Sep 12