594 Controls to the same direction

Created
06 Feb 2008
Status
Ballot PeriodIn the formal ballot, gathering the final votes and comments. Any signed-in reader may comment. Show the workflow
Part
Part 10 (2005)
Links
None
Page
35
Clause
Table 28
Paragraph
CtlN3
Category
Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue

Vendors should be able to allow open command of the breaker, even if the position indicates open position. Motivation: Personal safety: e.g. in some cases the position indication sensor could be jammed and opening is needed. Technically XCBR.BlkOpn/BlkCls (or CILO.EnaOpn/EnaCls) should be used if the opening is not possible due to internal condition of the breaker (spring charging, disconnector state). Closing breaker could still be inhibited if the position indication indicates close.

Part 7-2 17.2.2 does not directly inhibit above functionality but in conformance testing this functionality is not allowed.

Proposal

Allow the functionality descibed in issue in some cases or remove CtlN3.

DiscussionCreated
Ballot Period Accepted to remove CtlN3 18 Jun 08
Discussion (red) I totally agree with this statement. Furthermore, there should be no difference between an open or a close command : they are allowed regardless the actual position of the primary device. This is up to the user to define the requirements. No standardization is needed here.

In a system, the different behaviours may be implemented at the client level, e.g. HMI.

I support the removal of CtlN3.
06 Feb 08