436   Overturn Tissue 173

Created: 26 Oct 2006

Status: Not Applicable

Part: Part 6 (2004)

Links:

Page:

Clause:

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue

Tissue 173 should not have been entered as a General tissue. It reverses previous decisions made on 8-1 and does not allow control structures to be specified in SCL.

This was brought to light in a Tissue 433 entered on 8-1.

Proposal

Overturn the resolution of 173, put the CO structures back into 7-3 so that they can be properly specified in SCL. The SCL specification of the attributes must be backward compatible with the old SCL and structures of 7-3 prior to tissue 173 resolution

Discussion Created Status
The resolution of the TISSUE 433 is made with the TISSUE 168.
The TISSUE 173 resolves the relation between the 7-2 control services.
ctlVal, origin, ctlNum ... are service parameters of the control services (SBO with enhanced security, Operate, ...).
The CO data attributes defined in 7-3 ED1 are specialized data attributes, i.e. service paramters.
The mapping defines how those specialized data attributes are mapped (for 8-1 see Normative annex E.3 and E.4).
27 Oct 06 Not Applicable
The CO structures have nothing to do with the added structures in 8-1. The solution to 433 is clear now: within the 8-1 defined extensions 8-1 defines the attribute order. Everywhere where no order is defined, the ICD file determines the order of attributes on the IED. 27 Oct 06 Not Applicable

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer

Tissue DB v. 24.4.30.1