326 Order of data in SGCB is not defined
- Created
- 24 May 2006
- Status
- Not ApplicableClosed: the issue falls outside the scope of the standard. No further comments are taken. Show the workflow
- Part
- Part 8-1 (2004)
- Links
- None
- Page
- Clause
- Paragraph
- Category
- Issue for edition 2 of this part
Issue
The document does not specify anything on how to arrange the data of the SGCB. If we go as per section 7.3.1 of IEC61850-8-1 (page32), still it is not clear how to represent FC=SG coming under different LNs. We can treat the LNs also in the order as specified in IEC61850-7-4, but SGCB example given in section 13.1 (figure 17) of IEC61850-7-2 is totally different in the arrangement of data & LNs. Also Figure-3 of IEC61850-7-2 shows a relationship between dataset and SGCB, which is not defined anywhere else in the document.
Proposal
The setting group data (FC=SG) in SGCB has to be first arranged according to the LN (order specified in 7-4 or alphabetical order ) and then should be arranged as specified in 8-1. The examples given in section 13.1 (figure 17) should be corrected accordingly.This applies to Figure-3 of IEC61850-7-2 also.
| Discussion | Created |
|---|---|
|
Not Applicable
The exact statement, in 8-1, that accomplishes your proposal is found in clause 7.3.1 (page 32), paragraphs 1-3.
When sections of 8-1 are mute on ordering, clause 7.3.1 is the default. Therefore, 7-3 and 7-2 control the ordering of SGCB attributes. |
24 May 06 |