1764 Incorrect use of IEC62439-3 term "QuadBox"
- Created
- 03 Mar 2021
- Status
- AcceptedTaken up for processing. The detailed discussion follows. Show the workflow
- Part
- Part 90-4 (2020; Edition 2, Network Engineering)
- Links
- #1761 Wrong presentation of a HSR-PRP coupling device
- Page
- 267
- Clause
- 19.7.5
- Paragraph
- IED name="COUPLER"
Issue
This issue is related to recently submitted TISSUE #1761.
The description desc="Quad Box for connecting HSR ring to PRP network" is confusing. In IEC 62439-3(:2016) the term "QuadBox is only used to refer to a device coupling HSR rings, and that's how the term is known is the industry.
Proposal
Solution will depend on what the outcome of TISSUE #1761 will be.
Scenario 1:
If TISSUE #1761 is accepted and the 4-port coupler is replaced with two standard 3-port couplers, then this whole ICD file element has to be replaced anyway
Scenario 2:
If TISSUE #1761 is rejected and the 4-port coupler is retained in the figure and ICD file, then replace the term "QuadBox" with "4-port coupler" or similar.
| Discussion | Created |
|---|---|
|
Accepted
The term "Quadbox" is wrong, although a company could give it this name for a multi-functional device. To be corrected in the next edition.
|
04 Mar 21 |
| Triage Set links to 1761. | 04 Mar 21 |