1490 CmdBlk blocks itself?

Created
13 Apr 2016
Status
Not ApplicableClosed: the issue falls outside the scope of the standard. No further comments are taken. Show the workflow
Part
Part 7-4 (2010; Edition 2)
Links
None
Page
23
Clause
5.3.3
Paragraph
CmdBlk
Category
Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue

It is not clear that Common LN Data Object CmdBlk does not operate on itself

Proposal

Change explanation
From: "Blocking of control sequences and action triggers of controllable data objects"
To: Blocking of control commands and action triggers of controllable data objects in the LN except CmdBlk

DiscussionCreated
Not Applicable The tissue is not possible anymore to discuss within tissue process. It has been decided in the WG10 meeting to solve additional technical issues by comments from National Committees (NC) on CDV. Therefore is goes to blue.
However the question was forwarded to me and I included a comment to the list of the German NC (would be good to get it also through NC USA) So the issue will be solved within the standard process.
The proposal to improve the wording/description is accepted.
20 Apr 16
Discussion (red) A command to CmdBlk (as well as to Mod) is neither a (process) control command nor a (process related) action trigger. May be we need an enhanced vocabulary? 19 Apr 16