1245 GoosePerformanceTests, inconsistencies detected

Created

22 Apr 2014

Status

In Force (green)Closed: the solution is part of the standard. No further comments are taken. Show the workflow

Part

Part 10 (2012; Edition 2)

Links

None

Page

sveral

Clause

8.2.2, 8.2.3

Paragraph

several

Category

Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue

There are several statements in part 61850-10 not in line with other parts or the intention of the UCAIug Goose Performance Tests Procedures.

Proposal

1.Chapter 8.2.3.The performance Classes as mentioned in Part 10 are not in line with the one mentioned in part 5. In part 10 still the performance classes from Edition 1 are mentioned. The following performance classes shall be mentioned in relation to the GoosePerformanceTests:

P1 = 3 ms, P2 = 10 ms, P3 = 20 ms, P4 = 100 ms.

2.Chapter 8.2.2: To improve the test coverage it might be needed to increase the input triggers. Therefore part 10 shall state:

“The worst case, mean latency time and the standard deviation shall be computed across the responses to at least 1 000 input triggers.”