741   Cancel while in th WaitForChange state

This tissue has following status: blue

Created: 18 Jul 2011

Links:

Page: 164

Clause: Clause 20.3.3, Figure 42

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: It should be possible to cancel a control command while in the WaitForChange state. This is mainly true for the CDC APC and ISC.

Proposal: Add the transition [Cancel_req]/Cancel_resp+, CmdTerm_req to the WaitForChange state. The AddCause should be Abortion-by-cancel

Discussion Created Status
?
Ballot until Editor
24 Oct 11 blue
The basic assumption behind the current definition is, that an Operate triggers an action, which is not interruptable any more. Therefore, if for some reason the waiting time is too long, the operTimeout might get a shorter value to lead to an earlier Cmdterm, however a Cancel is NOT possible.
If you want to start an interruptable action, you need more than 1 data object and a logical node which does the command termination supervision, if this is not done from the client starting the action.
An APC e.g. is meant to be a set point as input to some regulatng and supervising function. It does NOT contain this function itself.
15 Sep 11 red
This issue also applies to Clause 20.3.2, figure 41 26 Jul 11 white

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer