Every status a technical issue can be in, and the steps the workflow allows between them. The status this tissue is in now is the box drawn in bold.

Hide the workflow

TissueDB status workflow back to Discussion Batch Triage Accepted Discussion Drafting Implementation Verify Draft Implementation Analysis Of Compatibility Conformance Test Preparation Conformance Test Verification Ballot Period Solution Accepted Must Implement In Force Approval (N/A) Approval (Duplicate) Approval (Editorial) Approval (Future Improvement) Not Applicable Duplicate Future Improvement Editorial Must Implement (Editorial) In Force (Editorial) Legend normal route of a technical solution accepted or released → in force classification branch (working group approval) back to Discussion for rework (lines are bundled) reaching the final state
The route a technical solution takes from Triage to In Force, the working group approvals that close an issue instead, and the ways back to Discussion for rework. Opens full size in a new tab.

857 Function/SubFunction for ConductingEquipment

Created
24 Jun 2012
Status
In Force (green)Closed: the solution is part of the standard. No further comments are taken. Hide the workflow
Part
Part 6 (2009-12; Edition 2)
Links
None
Page
49
Clause
9.2.4
Paragraph
Category
Issue may impact interoperability of implementations of Edition 2

Issue

Functional naming implies that there are no two logical node references (LNode) of the same LN class at any level within the Substation section. This was one of the reasons for introducing the Function/SubFunction elements.
However, these are not available for ConductingEquipment (nor for GeneralEquipment). This makes it impossible, for instance, to model redundant controlers (e.g., CSWI).
(Topic discussed during the WG10 meeting in Berlin.)

Proposal

Add a Function to tConductingEquipment ant tGeneralEquipment similar to Bay, VoltageLevel or Substation. However, the Function of a ConductingEquipment (or GeneralEquipment) shall differ from the Bay/Function in that it shall not allow to include other ConductingEquipments in order to avoid nested ConductingEquipments (or ConductingEquipments in GeneralEquipments).

DiscussionCreated
In Force (green) 24 Sep 12
Discussion (red) Accepted. This special Function element shall also be allowed at PowerTransformer, TransformerWinding and TapChanger elements 25 Jun 12
Triage Note: the "special" Function for tConductingEquipment ant tGeneralEquipment also requires a "special" SubFunction containing no child ConductingEquipment.
This tissue also applies to tSubEquipment.
24 Jun 12