1955 Relationship between GSESettings and GSE

Created
24 Jan 2025
Status
Discussion (red)Open for discussion while the solution is worked out. Any signed-in reader may comment. Show the workflow
Part
Part 6 (2025; Edition 2.2)
Links
None
Page
147
Clause
9.4.4
Paragraph
1

Issue

Some implementation consider that the GSESetting service is applicable also to GSE element, but as per 8-1 the GSE element and attributes shall be editable by the SCT.

The GSESetting is only about GOOSE control block attributes editability.

Proposal

Add a statement in GSE addres element indicating that GSE is always editable (creation, removal and edition of attributes) as soon as a GOOSE control block exists.

And add a statement in GSESetting service definition that it not applies to GSE.

This is also applicable to SMV

DiscussionCreated
Discussion (red) proposal to provide 10 Oct 25
Accepted accepted 10 Oct 25
Triage Agree with the proposal, Part 8-1 already mandates that the SCT is always allowed to edit the content of a GSE. Tissue 1956 is clarifying that it is also the case for SMV.
This should be treated as an interop tissue because it is creating interoperability issue during integration of devices.
10 Feb 25