1709 MMS services for Select ACSI services

Created
07 Aug 2020
Status
Not ApplicableClosed: the issue falls outside the scope of the standard. No further comments are taken. Show the workflow
Part
Part 8-1 (2020; Edition 2.1)
Links
None
Page
58
Clause
20.3
Paragraph
Table 94

Issue

In Table 94 and in the following clauses listed below, for SBOns Select the MMS Services are defined as "Read", where "Write" is expected.

Proposal

Occurrences
clause 20.3, Table 94
clause 20.4, Table 95
clause 20.5.1, "MMS write"
clause 20.5.2, Table 97
clause 20.5.3, "MMS Write.request"
clause 20.5.4, "MMS Write.response+" (add "+")
clause 20.5.5, "MMS Write.response+"

Change to "W", "Write" respectively.

In Table 95, for SBOns / Select / Response- the Access result "Success" should be changed to "Failure".

DiscussionCreated
Not Applicable Not Applicable 06 Dec 21
Approval (N/A) The service Select is a read request per MMS and has always been. Table 94, 95, and clause 20.5 are correct and consistent mapping the Select service to an mms read. 03 Sep 20