969   FtN1 Expected result in TPCL 1.5 is error message "file-non-existent"

View All Issues for Part 8-1 (2004)

If you want to see other tissues for this part.

This tissue has following status: blue

Created: 07 Jan 2013

Links:

Page: 39

Clause:

Paragraph: 9.3

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: In "IEC 61850 Server Test Procedures v2p3 with TPCL1p5.pdf" the expected result for the test FtN1 is an error message "file-non-existent".

But this error message does not exist "IEC 61850-8-1 Ed 1".

From the Table 18 the error message should be for Ed 1 "filename-syntax-error".

Proposal: Update IEC 61850 Server Test Procedures with 2 possible error messages depending of tested Edition?
By example:
Expected result for Edition 1 "filename-syntax-error"
Expected result for Edition 2 "file-non-existent"

Discussion Created Status
?		 Ballot until Editor
I agree with the fact that the ED.1/MMS combination should return the same error as ED.2 specifies. 21 Mar 13 blue
Since the tissue has been posted to Ed1 as an Ed2 TISSUE - and Edition 2 has already solved the issue in specifying that the proper behavior is to respond with an MMS Service Error {file, file-non-existent}, this is here also the proposal.
The proper response to a FileOpen specifying a file that is not available in the file system is an MMS Service Error {file, file-non-existent}
05 Mar 13 red

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer