728   BRCB: could PurgeBuf be set when RptEna=TRUE?

This tissue has following status: green

Created: 10 May 2011

Links:

Page: P94 & P97

Clause: 17.2.2.5 & Table37

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: There are some conflict in the standard on whether the value of PurgeBuf may be changed or not when RptEna = TRUE.

1. In IEC61850-7-2 Ed2.0,P97 17.2.2.5, the following descriptions are there
RptEna:
While in the state enabled, no changes of attribute values of the BRCB shall be allowed except triggering a general-integration.

According to this, no attribute value could be changed except "GI". So the PurgeBuf should not be changed.

2. But according to the table37, Attribute PurgeBuf does not have condition c1 or c2, which means PurgeBuf is not forbidden to be changed while the RptEna = TRUE.

Proposal: Decide whether PurgeBuf could be changed when RptEna=TRUE, then modify the standard accordingly with one of following way:

1. Change the statement in 17.2.2.5 with "BRCB shall be allowed except triggering a general-integration or purging the buffer.", indicates purgeBuf can be changed at any time.
And also change the Figure 24 state machine accordingly.Or

2. Add the c2 should be added to the PurgeBuf line, which indicates the PurgeBuf may only be set when RptEna = FALSE.

Discussion Created Status
?
Ballot until Editor
02 May 12 green
Solution 2 is also aligned with IEC 61850-8-1 and therefore set to final proposal 24 Oct 11 final proposal
Solution 2 is in line with Edition 1 and Figure 24 of Edition 2, and should therefore be taken. 16 May 11 red

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer