348   URCB class and report

Created: 21 Jul 2006

Status: In Force (green)

Part: Part 7-2 (2003)

Links:

Page: 092, 93

Clause: 14.2.4.

Paragraph: 14.2.5.2

Category: Issue may impact interoperability of implementations of Edition 1

Issue

Clause 14.2.5.2 says "The report service shall be as defined for BRCB in 14.2.3.2, except that the parameter BufOvfl of the report format shall not be available."

But this is not possible for TimeOfEntry which becomes the report time stamp, because according to the report definition in table 24 TimeOfEntry exists only TOGETHER with EntryID if BOTH report-time-stamp = TRUE AND entryID = TRUE in optFlds (see note b).

Proposal

Allow TimeOfEntry (report time stamp) of URBC reports to exist independent of missing EntryID.

Discussion Created Status
changed to green. The 7-2 clauses for reporting and logging ( Edition 1) can be found at ftp.sisconet.com. Username=wg10revision pw: iec61850. Passive FTP must be used for retrieval. 16 Feb 07 In Force (green)
see Tissue 453 for revised text. TimeOfEntry of exist independantly to EntryID 14 Dec 06 Ballot Period
I suggest that the text be modfied to exclude sending EntryID or TimeOfEntry. The timestamp of the Report is already another OptFlds parameter.

Suggest adding a conditional note to URCB Table for OptFlds.EntryID:

"c3: It is a local issue if a SetURCBValues with OptFlds.EntryID = TRUE should result with a GetURCBValues of OptFlds.EntryID = TRUE. It is suggested that a GetURCBValues of OptFlds.EntryID return a value of FALSE for OptFlds.EntryID."

Additionally, suggest that clause 14.2.5.2 be revised to:

"The report service shall be as defined for BRCB in 14.2.3.2, exception of:
• the parameter BufOvfl of the report format shall not be available.
• Regardless of the value of OptFlds.EntryID, no EntryID shall be included in the Report"
19 Oct 06 Discussion (red)

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer

Tissue DB v. 23.12.13.1