1765   IED can only have one basic namesapce

Created: 04 Mar 2021

Status: Discussion (red)

Part: Part 7-1 (2020; Edition 2.1)

Links:

Page: 113

Clause: 13.5.1

Paragraph: 1

Issue

The standard does not explicitly state the obvious requirement that a server presents services at exactly one revision of the standard, therefore all ldNs must inherit from the same namespaces.

Perhaps it could be argued to make the distinction at the server, but IED seems more reasonable.

Proposal

Change first bullet in the list from

"whole logical device"

to

"whole physical device"

Discussion Created Status
Proxy case needs further consideration. 11 Jul 23 Discussion (red)
Editor discussion 2021-Mar-16 was "whole server" but final proposal is "whole physical device". Why does the 2023-Feb-28 proposal differ from the consensus of the 7-2 editors?
I suggest change "whole logical device" to "whole server" 		09 Jun 23 Verify Draft Implementation
No objection, proceed to next state. 09 Jun 23 Verify Draft Implementation
Change first bullet in the list from

"whole logical device"

to

"whole physical device" 		28 Feb 23 Drafting Implementation
move to discussion 01 Feb 22 Discussion (red)
7-2 Editors:

All (non-proxied) Logical Devices of a server will implement the same basic namespace.

In a physical device containing multiple servers, individual servers may (when necessary) implement different basic namespaces.

Proposal: change first bullet in the list from "whole logical device" to "whole server"
16 Mar 21 Accepted

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer

Tissue DB v. 23.8.4.2