Issue has been raised by Adhoc Task Force Communication Supervision during the teleconference 18th of June 2020.
As it is requested to have only one DO instance of GocbTrk in the server, it make not possible to get both tracking of GoCB for Layer 2 GOOSE and GoCB for UDP/IP GOOSE. This is due to different types of PhyComAddr required that leads to get two DOTypes.
Same issue exists for MsvcbTrk and service tracking of UPD/IP SV.
Proposal
The group suggests to create :
* a new DO GocbUdpTrk implementing CDC GTS dedicated for the tracking of routable GOOSE Control Block. Existing GocbTrk DO is reserved for tracking of GoCB used for Layer 2 GOOSE.
* a new DO MsvcbUdpTrk implementing CDC MTS dedicated for the tracking of routable multicast SV Control Block. Existing MsvcbTrk DO is reserved for tracking of MSVCB used for Layer 2 SV.
Discussion
Created
Status
Starting ballot period
22 Jan 24
Ballot Period
https://redmine.ucaiug.org/issues/6614
22 Jan 24
Conformance Test Verification
Change to state: Conformance Test Preparation
15 Nov 23
Conformance Test Preparation
The solution of #1701 adresses following compatibility use cases (part 7-1, annex K, table K-2):
UC 5a - Extend existing LN with new DO: GocbUdpTrk (CDC GTS) and MsvcbUdpTrk (CDC MTS).
Further, for existing DO (GocbTrk, MsvcbTrk)) in LTRK a new SCL specification (schema 2017B5) for these already existing DO is given.
For explanation of the use of these DO the descriptions are adapted.
--> no backward compatibility issue for part 7-4
30 Oct 23
Analysis Of Compatibility
updated implementation based on NSD 2017B5 schema - 2017B5 will be distributed with the IEC 61850-7-7 AMD1.
08 Dec 21
Verify Draft Implementation
the attached draft implementation illustrates how the tissue resolution will apply in the NSDs.
New NSD schema is required.
16 Mar 21
Verify Draft Implementation
I think we can start verifying the draft implementation
03 Nov 20
Verify Draft Implementation
Proposal to change descriptions of DO in LNclass LTRK:
GocbTrk - Access service tracking for layer 2 GOOSE control blocks
MsvcbTrk - Access service tracking for layer 2 multicast sampled values control blocks
Add the following DO in LNclass LTRK:
GocbUdpTrk (CDC GTS) - Access service tracking for routable GOOSE control blocks
MsvcbUdpTrk (CDC MTS)- Access service tracking for routable multicast sampled values control blocks
Presense condition for both new DO: o / na.
04 Sep 20
Drafting Implementation
I would agree with the proposal. Just had a case today where I was confronted with that problem.
I move the TISSUE to discussion, and we should discuss if we agree that it is InterOp or if it shall be Future improvement. I would support Thierry to make it interop