1500   the response for DeleteNamedVariableList with a non-existent LN is not specified

Created: 06 Jun 2016

Status: In Force (green)

Part: Part 8-1 (2011; Edition 2)

Links:

Page: 45

Clause: 8.1.3.4.3.6 DeleteNamedVariableList

Paragraph:

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue

The definition for response to DeleteNamedVariableList with a non-existent LN is not specified in any bullet section.

Proposal

Add the definition for response to DeleteNamedVariableList with a non-existent LN as:
"
A DeleteNamedVariableList-Request that specifies an objectScope of domainSpecific and MMS NamedVariable (e.g. Logical Node) and specifies a NamedVariable that is non-existent. If the requested NamedVariable does not exist, the MMPM shall return a a MMS Confirmed-Error PDU. The ServiceError, within the Confirmed-ErrorPDU shall be errorClass="access" with an errorCode="object-non-existent".
"

Discussion Created Status
The Tissue resolution is - agreement with the proposal of July 22nd.
Not agree with the original tissue proposal made by tissue issuer.
"
the problem exists (only) in the context of CreateDataSet / DefineNamedVariableList.
Proposal :add a bullet:
• A DefineNamedVariableList-Request that specifies an objectScope=”domainSpecific” and specifies a variableListName which does not contain the name of an exixting MMS NamedVariable. In this case, the MMPM shall return a MMS Confirmed-ErrprPDU shall be errorClass=”access” with an errorCode=”object-non-existent” 		08 Nov 16 In Force (green)
BALLOT DATE EXPIRED 08 Nov 16 In Force (green)
Agree. Moving to final proposal. 31 Aug 16 Ballot Period
I agree with Bruce that the problem exists (only) in the context of CreateDataSet / DefineNamedVariableList.
Proposal :add a bullet:
• A DefineNamedVariableList-Request that specifies an objectScope=”domainSpecific” and specifies a variableListName which does not contain the name of an exixting MMS NamedVariable. In this case, the MMPM shall return a MMS Confirmed-ErrprPDU shall be errorClass=”access” with an errorCode=”object-non-existent”. 		22 Jul 16 Discussion (red)
Same problem exists for "CreateDataSet".
7-2 requires persistent dataset names to be "LDName/LNName.DataSetName". If LNName is wrong then this is an illegal request. Question is: Should a server refuse a request where LNName is incorrect or should it ignore the "correctness". part 8-1 mapping over MMS allows "don't care about name" but other mappings MIGHT not be forgiving to wrong LNName. 		20 Jul 16 Discussion (red)

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer

Tissue DB v. 23.12.13.1