1245   GoosePerformanceTests, inconsistencies detected

This tissue has following status: green

Created: 22 Apr 2014


Page: sveral

Clause: 8.2.2, 8.2.3

Paragraph: several

Category: Issue for edition 2 of this part

Issue: There are several statements in part 61850-10 not in line with other parts or the intention of the UCAIug Goose Performance Tests Procedures.

Proposal: 1.Chapter 8.2.3.The performance Classes as mentioned in Part 10 are not in line with the one mentioned in part 5. In part 10 still the performance classes from Edition 1 are mentioned. The following performance classes shall be mentioned in relation to the GoosePerformanceTests:

P1 = 3 ms, P2 = 10 ms, P3 = 20 ms, P4 = 100 ms.

2.Chapter 8.2.2: To improve the test coverage it might be needed to increase the input triggers. Therefore part 10 shall state:

“The worst case, mean latency time and the standard deviation shall be computed across the responses to at least 1 000 input triggers.”

Discussion Created Status
Ballot until Editor
Changed to green 20 May 14 green
As agreed during the UCAIUG testing subcommitte telco we accept the proposal.
- use the P1..P4 classes from IEC 61850-5 Ed2
- add "at least" before 1000
05 May 14 final proposal 19 may 2014


Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer