1199   Allow INT32 for CDC BCR

This tissue has following status: green

Created: 05 Jan 2014

Links:

Page: 26

Clause: 7.3.8

Paragraph: Table 20 (BCR CDC)

Category: Issue may impact interoperability of implementations of Edition 1

Issue: UCAIug Ed1 conformance tests have been accepting INT32 as the type of attributes actVal and frVal of Common Data Class BCR since the beginning of conformance testing; but this has never been part of the accepted TISSUES and is therefore makes many existing devices technically non-conformant.

To remedy this, UCAIug proposes to now allow INT32 as an alternative to the INT128 specified in the standard. If this TISSUE is not approved, then all conformant devices will be forced to adopt INT128 as the size of counters.

INT64 has already been adopted by IEC for Ed2 to replace all uses of Ed1 INT128

Proposal: Change Table 20 (BCR CDC specification) rows "actVal" and "frVal" from "INT128" to "INT32 or INT128"

Discussion Created Status
?
Ballot until Editor
Changed to green 06 May 14 green
As agreed during the UCAIUG telco of 16 april 2014 we change the recommendation from 14 april into a shall. The BCR.actVal/frVal shall be INT32 in SCL as well as in MMS. 16 Apr 14 final proposal April 23, 2014
SCL type declaration and MMS used type must be identical.
It is wrong to allow a DAI actVal bType=INT128, to map to an MMS Signed 32 bit.
I would recommend to only allow INT32 for actVal and frVal in both representation (MMS and SCL).
14 Apr 14 final proposal
Changed the category to IntOp1. The scope of this tissue is Edition1 only (for edition 2 the type is INT64). 03 Apr 14 final proposal April 10, 2014

 

Privacy | Contact | Disclaimer